Thursday, April 09, 2015



The OIA is not a petition mechanism

Last year, we saw an organised campaign using FYI [down, but will be up again] to lodge OIA requests with Tim Groser demanding the release of the draft text of the TPPA. The aim was to show support for release, effectively using the OIA as a petition mechanism. All it resulted in was 50 form-letter refusals.

And now there's another similar campaign, this one over EQC. Unlike the previous one, which asked people to lodge their own requests, this one asks people to "add their electronic signature in support of an Official Information Act (OIA) Request". The implication is that this will lend the request more weight. It won't. Instead, its a pointless exercise which mistakes the OIA for a petition process. But that's not what the OIA is about. The purpose of the Act isn't to help people voice their grievances about the government, but "to make official information more freely available". Whether information is released is (supposed to be) decided on the merits and in accordance with the principle of availability, not on how many people want it. So unless you're the first person to request something, or you have another angle which might excavate different information, "adding your signature" to an OIA request or submitting duplicate requests has no effect whatsoever - and to the extent it results in form responses, it actually undermines the latter.

As for the request itself, it falls into all the usual pitfalls: a political preamble which invites the responding agency to treat it as correspondence rather than a request; a question-and-answer format; trying to get all the answers at once. These are pretty much guaranteed to result in an unhappy OIA experience:

The UK establishment as a boy band

The UK is going to the polls next month in the most uncertain election in decades. This has already produced some great political ads. and now its produced this one:


[The good bit starts 20 seconds in]

While its structured as a gag, its a pointy one. The UK has a political establishment. All the major political parties belong to it, because they all went to the same private schools and posh universities and came out of them sharing the same world view. As a result, it doesn't really matter who you vote for - with a few tweaks around the edges, you'll get the same package of war, racism, austerity, privatisation, vilification of the poor and grovelling subservience to the bankers of the City. And with an unfair electoral system shutting out alternative voices, its no wonder that a third of UKanians no longer bother to vote. What's the point, if the only real decision is which colour tie the toff who fucks you over will be wearing?

With a Parliament that no longer represents its people, the UK desperately needs electoral reform. But that seems absolutely impossible under the current system.

A battle, but not the war

Unite has won a significant victory in the war against zero-hours contracts:

Zero-hour contracts have been abandoned for workers at a group of fast-food chains, who will now be guaranteed hours of work.

Restaurant Brands has committed to end zero-hour contracts by July, in a collective agreement struck with Unite Union. The deal covers workers at KFC, Starbucks, Pizza Hut and Carl's Jr.

Under the controversial zero-hour contracts, workers had to be available for work but had no guaranteed hours per week.

Unite Union said its bargaining team unanimously supported the proposal, which guaranteed a worker at least 80 per cent of the average hours they had worked over a three-month period.


Its not full job security, but its far better than they've had before, and gives these workers some predictability about their income. But the war isn't over - McDonald's, Burger King and Wendy's are still fully committed to these unfair labour practices. As usual, Unite is working through public pressure, with a mass-mailing campaign to show public opposition (you can sign that here). Boycotts are likely to be next (and I'll be noting that in my letter), and if these businesses value their public reputation, they'll be following Restaurant Brands in guaranteeing hours.

But while it will be great to eliminate zero-hours contracts from the fast food industry, that's still not the war. These contracts are pervasive throughout the retail sector, driven by employers desire to cut costs and keep workers insecure and under control. And we won't eliminate them entirely except by legislation. The government is promising to do that, but we know it'll be half-arsed and full of loopholes. There are currently two members bills in the ballot to eliminate zero hours contracts and give workers certainty. While there's a chance they'll be drawn and passed with the new anti-National majority in Parliament, the only way to guarantee the passage of such legislation is to change the government.

Wednesday, April 08, 2015



A cover-up in Ireland

Ireland has a problem: its refugee system doesn't work. Asylum seekers face long delays in having their claims processed. But the Irish government has a solution: exclude information from refugee agencies from their Freedom of Information Act:

The Irish Refugee Council has expressed its “concern” at the manner in which restrictions to the Freedom of Information Act, as it applies to bodies dealing with asylum and refugee issues, were “rushed” through the Oireachtas before Easter.

Both Houses debated and approved the restrictions on the date from which the records of two refugee bodies - Refugee Appeals Tribunal and the Refugee Applications Commissioner - can be now be accessed under the Act.

While the Act applies from April 21st, 2008, and the public can apple for records dating form then, the new restrictions mean records from these bodies can only be applied for from October 14th, 2014.


Needless to say, this won't solve any of the underlying problems with Ireland's refugee agencies. But it will stop anyone from finding out how bad those problems really are. Which is clearly all the irish government cares about.

Who will end the former MPs travel rort?

Last month, in another example of MPs earning their reputation, the government tried to double the travel perks of retired MPs by stealth. They backed down, but it brought the matter to public attention again. Last night, Campbell Live did a detailed piece on it, which showed how completely unjustified these perks are. The poll at the end was unsurprising: 99% of respondents thought that these perks should be abolished.

That's a pretty overwhelming public endorsement, and it suggests that whichever MP or party wants to do it will reap some political rewards. So, who wants to do it? I've drafted the bill. Is there any MP in the House brave enough to stand up for the public against their senior colleagues (including the Speaker, who is a member of the 75% club) and put it in the ballot? Or will the cosy conspiracy of silence around these rorts continue?

(As for the chances of success, National and Labour - dominated by members of the 90% club - have said they would vote against abolition. But we've already seen how they fold on the issue when confronted with public pressure, and I expect them to again. After all, the cost of protecting Goff, McCully and the rest will be high, and I don't think their backbenchers, who don't get these perks, have any appetite whatsoever for paying it).

Ending the UK's biggest tax rort

The UK is going to the polls next month, and Labour's Ed Miliband has finally offered a genuinely left-wing policy among all the promises of even harsher austerity and harder kicking of the poor: eliminating the UK's biggest tax rort: "non-dom" tax status:

Ed Miliband will promise to end a colonial-era symbol of inequity in the tax system by announcing that, if he wins the election, he will abolish the non-domicile rule that allows many of Britain’s richest permanent residents to avoid paying tax in the UK on their worldwide income.

Labour will say the rule, introduced by William Pitt the Younger in the late 18th century, has been wide open to abuse and offends the moral basis of taxation. Everyone who has made the UK their permanent home should pay full UK tax on all their income and gains, he will argue.

In a speech in Warwick on Wednesday, Miliband is expected to say the non-dom rule, believed to be used by more than 110,000 wealthy people in a system unique to the UK, is born of a discredited belief that “anything goes for those at the top and that what is good for the rich is always good for Britain”.

Non-doms pay UK income tax and capital gains tax on their UK sources of income and gains, and whatever income generated overseas they choose to remit to the UK. By contrast, UK domiciles have to pay tax on all of their income and gains, wherever in the world they are made – Britain or overseas.


This isn't about immigrants or permanent residents, but about people born in the UK who pretend to live overseas for tax purposes, based on "links" as tenuous as a foreign newspaper subscription or a grave plot (which can of course simply be purchased). They use this to dodge their taxes while the money piles up, enjoying all the benefits of living in the UK, but none of the costs.

Naturally, the tories are screaming that these people who aren't paying tax in the UK will all flee and not pay tax somewhere else, to which any sensible person would say "good riddance". After all, they're not paying tax, so what's the supposed loss? Their good company? They're sociopathic parasites, and the UK is better off without them.

Meanwhile, on the same day Miliband announces this, he gets endorsed by tax-cheating war criminal Tony Blair. I wonder how many more seats the SNP will get out of that?

Justice for drone strikes?

In December 2009, a US drone strike killed the brother and son of Pakistani man Haji Abdul Karim Khan. Since then, he's been fighting for justice through the courts. And now it seems he might finally get some:

The Islamabad High Court (IHC) directed on Tuesday the Secretariat police station to register a case against former CIA station chief Jonathan Banks for his alleged role in a surgical strike that killed the family members of an anti-drone activist.

The court directed Islamabad Police Chief IGP Tahir Alam to register a case against the former CIA official for killing innocent civilians in drone strikes.

Haji Abdul Karim Khan, a native of Mirali, North Waziristan, had requested the court to register an FIR after his relatives, including his son Zahinullah and brother Asif Iqbal, and other civilians were killed in a drone attack in December 31, 2009.


The Pakistani government have apparently been dragging their feet on this, refusing to open a case because it would harm diplomatic relations. Earlier this year they even had him disappeared to prevent him from testifying to the European Parliament about drone strikes. But they're running out of places to hide. Hopefully this means that the law will be enforced, and that we'll soon see an extradition order so this CIA murderer can stand trial.

Tuesday, April 07, 2015



Something to be proud of

NZ has ranked 5th in the world on the Social Progress Index. Last year we were first, but apparently there has been a significant change in methodology which makes the two results incommensurable. But its not all good news:

New Zealand did particularly well in the "person rights" category, ranking number one for freedom of expression and political rights.

It also ranked third on "access to basic knowledge" and performed well on access to communications, tolerance and inclusion and freedom of religion.

However the country did less well on access to nutrition and basic medical care, partly because of our high child mortality rate.

Environmental sustainability was also something to work on, with poor water management a particular concern.


Children's rights and the environment are our Achilles' heels - and the very issues the government is ignoring. But think of how much better we'd do if every child in New Zealand was well-fed, and every river was clean. sadly, we're not going to get either under this government.

This is what an underfunded watchdog looks like

Last year, we learned that then-Justice Minister Judith Collins had taken time off on a taxpayer-funded trip to China to endorse her husband's company in violation of Cabinet Manual conflict of interest rules (and basic standards of propriety). When confronted with this, Prime Minister John Key first claimed that the Cabinet Office had said it was all OK, then admitted that he had lied and misled the public.

Cabinet Office advice on conflicts of interest is normally ironclad, kept secret so Ministers will continue to seek it. But the Prime Minister's public deceit opened a chink in that defence, as the Ombudsman had specifically cited deceit as a reason for disclosure. So, I requested the advice under the OIA. Naturally, the Cabinet Office refused. Naturally, I complained to the Ombudsman. That was a year ago. And a year on, I'm still waiting. The only communication I've had from them has been an email issuing me a complaint number.

This isn't surprising. In 2013-14 the Ombudsman were funded for only two-thirds of the number of complaints they actually receive, with the result that they managed to resolve only 44% of all non-priority investigations within a year. So, I guess I'm just one of the 56% who has to wait longer. At the same time, its very clearly not how the system is supposed to work. The Ombudsman is supposed to be a watchdog, holding Ministers and officials to account and ensuring that their decisions comply with the law. But they can't do that job if they're not resourced to do it in a timely fashion. And the net result is Ministers and officials making poor or blatantly unlawful decisions, secure in the knowledge that a complaint will never be brought, or if one is brought, it will take so long to resolve that they will have moved on and it will all be old news anyway. And so rather than being a check on decisions, the complaints process simply becomes another for of defence for decision-makers...

And the consequences are right there in the Ombudsman's annual report: people have stopped complaining about late responses, because they know there's no point. And so underfunding leads directly to unaccountability for unlawful behaviour.

This isn't good enough. We need an OIA complaints system that actually functions in a timely fashion. And that means properly funding the Ombudsman's Office so they can cope with the workload they actually have, not the workload they had ten years ago. Anything less is a direct attack on transparency.

New Fisk

The Christian tragedy in the Middle East did not begin with Isis
Iran nuclear deal: A powerful Tehran turned into America’s policeman in the Gulf? It could happen

Thursday, April 02, 2015



Political satire is legal again



Back in August, Darren Watson and Jeremy Jones put this amusing political song on the internet and offered it for radio broadcast. The Electoral Commission immediately banned it as an "electoral advertisement" - in the process effectively declaring effective political satire to be illegal. Watson and Jones challenged the Commission's interpretation, and the court has finally ruled - finding that the song and video aren't advertisments at all, but comment, speech and content. Which should have been pretty bloody obvious the moment anyone stopped to think about it.

The full judgement is here. There's a long traversal of the legislative history of the relevant parts of the Electoral Act and Broadcasting Acts, and a discussion of the interests Parliament is trying to protect through the electoral law requirements to attach promoter statements to advertisements and the prohibition on election programmes. And the short version is that they're trying to prevent people from buying elections, not from commenting on politics or producing protest songs. A rights-consistent interpretation of our electoral law has to support that, and fortunately one could be found by highlighting the distinction between advertising and actual content. That works very well for this situation (where, pretty obviously, its not an "advertisement" at all), but there are likely to be further interpretational questions around stealth advertising campaigns. but I guess the Commission, with the guidance of the courts, will deal with them as they come up.

In passing, its also worth noting that the Electoral Commission really did try and ban satire. Yes, they deny it, but that would have been the effect of their argument at paragraph 90 where they argue for a top-down "encourages votes / specified exception" scheme and that

Satirical speech might or might not be an election advertisement, depending upon the “may reasonably be regarded” assessment.

But no reasonable person would conclude that effective satire didn't encourage people not to vote for its targets. While it may not be its purpose, that's the effect of a thorough skewering - to highlight views the public may find repulsive, and lower the public's opinion of the target. And the idea that such speech might be forbidden in a free and democratic society is simply laughable. Which may explain why we don't see very much of it on NZ television (that, and NZ On Air is hardly going to allocate funding to content which skewers the people who set its budget).

But I guess that's what you get when your Electoral Commission is more worried about getting flak from politicians rather than protecting the public's democratic rights.

Ministerial vetoes and freedom of information

The Liberal Democrats want to eliminate the Ministerial veto from the UK's Freedom of Information Act:

An end to the ministerial veto that allows the attorney general to over turn decisions of the information tribunal – a veto power that was restricted by the supreme court in its landmark decision in March paving the way for the release of letters written by Prince Charles to ministers in 2004-05. The case took 10 years after the attorney general overruled the information commissioner, the official responsible for arbitrating on decisions concerning the Freedom of Information Act.
Good. As the Supreme Court pointed out, the veto is inconsistent with the rule of law. In the UK, judges decide on releases, and it is constitutionally inappropriate to allow Ministers to overrule them simply because they don't like the decision.

So what about New Zealand? We also have a Ministerial veto, though it hasn't been used since 1987. But we also have a different oversight scheme. The Ombudsman isn't a part of the judiciary, and so the rule of law issue isn't so strong.

Even so, I'd like to see it eliminated. At present, the government wields the threat of the veto to water down Ombudsman's decisions and deter release. Or, as the Law Commission put it, to "moderate decision-making". Ministers (and unelected officials like the Cabinet Secretary) literally say "if you find against us, we will veto". And that's simply not how the system should work. Decisions on the release or withholding of official information should be made on the merits, not because recommending release "might adversely affect the Ombudsmen’s relationship with the Executive", and not because of Ministerial intimidation.

Yeah, nah

Phil Goff is outraged because the government is planning to close down some operations of the Armed Forces Canteen Council and put them out to tender. What's the Armed Forces Canteen Council? A statutory body established to "provide amenities on service establishments for the benefit of members of the Armed Forces and of other persons employed or residing on those establishments". Which, in English, means cafes, convenience stores, and a network of duty-free stores. Its exempt from income tax and liquor laws. And yet, it makes bugger-all money - an average of $630,000 a year, most of which is disbursed to military welfare funds.

The reason for this? Reading their annual reports (latest here), it seems that generals just aren't very good at running cafes.

There's an argument for the NZDF or a subsidiary body to run base shops where there's nothing else around - in Scott Base, for example (though really, given the terms of the Antarctic Treaty, that should be under the NZ Antarctic institute, not NZDF). But most of the AFCC's business is done in places like Devonport and Linton and Waiouru and Trentham, where there are plenty of other options. They even run the Waiouru Four Square, which isn't even on the base - its on State Highway One, catering to tourists, not soldiers.

I oppose privatisation. But here it seems like there's not even a shred of a case for government ownership of most of these facilities. If soldiers want a flat white or moro bar (or, apparently, a washing machine or digital camera), there's no reason for a special statutory body to provide it to them. They can go to a shop like anybody else. And it'll probably be cheaper - AFCC consistently complains about its inability to compete with other retailers.

The Armed Forces Canteen Council's predecessor, the Canteen Board, was founded to provide basic facilities to conscripted soldiers in vast military camps or on deployment overseas. But there's just no need for it in peacetime. Time to put it out of its misery.

Pepetual secrecy in Britian

Why was Erol Incedal acquitted of terrorism charges? Was the prosecution even justified in the first place, or was it all a government stitch-up? We'll never know, because the secrecy in Britain's secret "trial" has been made permanent:

Before sentencing the two men at the Old Bailey in London on Wednesday, Mr Justice Nicol rejected an application from 11 media organisations for the reporting restrictions to be lifted.

Anthony Hudson QC, counsel for the media, had argued that there was a “legitimate and substantial public interest” in the public being permitted to learn why Incedal had been acquitted.

In rejecting the application, Nicol handed down two judgments - one open, and one secret. His open judgment said that crown prosecutors could be dissuaded from bringing such a case in the future if reporting restrictions were varied, and concluded: “For reasons which I can only explain in the accompanying private judgment, I reject Mr Hudson’s application.”


The decision will almost certainly be appealed by the media all the way to the ECHR if necessary. Secret trials are fundamentally incompatible with the principle of open justice and the right to a fair trial, and they fatally undermine public confidence in the justice system. Sadly, the british establishment, as represented by its judges, seems incapable of recognising this.

Meanwhile, Incedal was sentenced to 42 months for possession of a bomb-making manual. How does that stack up against other sentences in similar cases? Well, in this one a defendant received 24 months for posession of not just a bomb-making manual, but an actual live bomb and a stash of other weapons. The difference? He was a member of the English Defence League, not a Muslim. Terrorism, it seems, is a more severe crime if you are brown rather than white.

Closing a loophole in the OIA

A key part of National's confidence and supply agreement with ACT is the appointment of ACT's sole MP David Seymour as Parliamentary Under Secretary to the Minister of Education and Parliamentary Under Secretary to the Minister for Regulatory Reform. Its pure patronage, providing Seymour with staff, a fancy title and a $25,000 pay rise in exchange for doing nothing (Seymour has no delegated authorities). But the appointment exposed a hole in the OIA, in that Parliamentary Under Secretaries are not covered, despite theoretically doing important government work.

Now Labour's Adrian Rurawhe is proposing to fix that hole, with a Member's Bill which would bring PUS's under the OIA. The mechanism is simple: insert a definition of "Minister of the Crown" which includes PUSes. If it passes, we'd be able to ask David Seymour exactly what it is that he does in exchange for that $25,000 a year. The question is whether the supposedly pro-transparency, pro-accountability ACT MP will vote for it.

Correction: So, Seymour does in fact have delegated authorities; I missed them because PUSes were at the end of the file. I apologise for the error.

Wednesday, April 01, 2015



The cost of GCSB spying

What's the cost of the GCSB's mass-surveillance of the Pacific? "Fewer whistleblowers, more corruption, less stability", according to Public Address:

Fewer whistleblowers, more corruption, less stability.

That's the assessment of longtime Pacific journalist Jason Brown of the impact of the revelation that the GCSB has been conducting "full take" collection of communications in Samoa, Fiji, Solomon Islands and other Pacific nations since 2009.

"It creates fear. We live in small communities," he said on Media Take last night. "The advent of email was actually, we thought, a bit of a boon in that we could communicate within our communities without actually having to meet anyone ... that small-town thing of everyone knowing what you're doing and people being very sensitive to being critical of the government. So we thought email was great.

"Now that the knowledge is out there, the number of whistleblowers, people who leak us information, is probably going to drop a bit, if it hasn't already, because they know that they're being watched ...

"More corruption is an inevitable result. It's difficult enough getting stories in the Pacfiic when you're working in these small communities. And everyone's rightfully concerned for their jobs. If there's more corruption there's less stability. And that's even going to have a long-term effect on New Zealand."


Again, it is hard to see how promoting corrupt and unstable government on our backdoor is in the interests of New Zealanders, or how it contributes to our national security, international relations, or economic well-being. These aren't just our neighbours, whose problems will spill over here - they're supposedly our friends. Undermining their democracies isn't just evil and stupid, its also a betrayal of those close relationships.

But I guess that's just the sort of stupidity that happens when your intelligence policy is made in Washington to serve American interests, not in Wellington to serve ours.

Our mass-surveillance of the Pacific isn't just wrong, a violation of the privacy of entire societies - it is also stupid. And it must stop.

No good reason for secrecy

Defence Minister Gerry Brownlee recently returned from Iraq with an impunity agreement enabling the deployment of New Zealand troops. But he's refusing to release it:

Labour has attacked the degree of secrecy about the preparation of a New Zealand troop deployment to Iraq.

The ABC in Australia revealed yesterday that New Zealand troops had begun training with the Australian Defence Force in Australia.

And while Defence Minister Gerry Brownlee said he had a "satisfactory agreement" with the Iraqi Government on legal protections for New Zealand troops on deployment, he said he would not be releasing it for security reasons.


But the security of the soldiers, or the political "security" of the Minister? Because there's only one reason to keep this agreement secret: if it doesn't match what the parties are publicly saying about it. Either it doesn't provide NZ troops with the legal protection Brownlee says it does, or it provides more than the Iraqi regime is willing to admit to. Either way, protecting a government's ability to lie to its people is not a good reason in a democracy to keep something secret. This agreement should be released, so then we can all see what the truth is.

The cost of corporate tax cheating in Australia

How much does corporate tax-cheating cost us? In Australia, A$25 billion a year - enough to eliminate two-thirds of the government budget deficit:

Australia's biggest 900 companies claimed tax deductions and exemptions worth a total $25 billion last year – enough to wipe out two-thirds of the current federal budget deficit at a stroke.

As Treasurer Joe Hockey prompted a national "conversation" about tax reform, including the prospect of a higher and broader GST, the Australian Tax Office's own data showed the top 900 companies paid an "effective tax rate" of just 19.3 cents in the dollar on pre-tax profits in 2014.

The corporate tax rate is 30 per cent.

Companies now pay proportionately less tax on their income than the average wage-earning Australian.


And because companies are overwhelmingly owned by the ultra-wealthy, what this means is that the 1% are directly benefiting from this corporate tax-cheating, while ordinary Australians are paying for it through reduced public services and higher personal taxes.

It would be fascinating to see similar statistics for New Zealand. Last year, NZ companies paid almost $6.5 billion in company tax. If the proportion of cheating is similar to that in Australia, they're scamming us for ~$2 billion a year. Which was the difference between surplus and deficit last year, and an amount which would make a huge difference to our public health and education systems. And its hard to escape the conclusion that those systems are being rundown because of the sociopathic selfishness of our corporations.

A victory on freshwater

Fresh water quality is one of the big environmental battlegrounds in New Zealand, with the government hellbent on destroying it for the profit of its cronies in the dairy sector, while the public understandably wants rivers which are safe to swim in. Now the Environment Court has made a significant decision in that battle:

The Fish and Game organisation is hailing an Environment Court ruling on water quality management in Hawke's Bay as a landmark decision which will have implications for other regions.

Hawke's Bay iwi Ngati Kahungunu challenged the Regional Council's proposal to change the way it manages water quality in its regional plan.

Fish and Game environmental manager Corina Jordan said Judge Thompson of the Environmental Court had rejected the Council's approach to manage the overall quality of water by allowing a decline in some areas to be balanced out by an improvement in others.

Why is this significant? Because National's new National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management - the one that sets a "bottom line" of rivers that will make you sick - seems to advocate exactly that approach, by setting an objective that
The overall quality of fresh water within a region is maintained or improved...
Its draft implementation guidance for local authorities is even more explict:
Objective A2 recognises that maintaining all aspects of water quality everywhere may not be possible or desirable, economically or socially. It does not require every water body to be improved in a region; some will remain in their current state (unless they are below national bottom lines or have been degraded by human activities to the point of over-allocation). The freshwater objective-setting process outlined in part CA of the NPS-FM provides a process to assist with this decision-making.

Objective A2 allows for some variability in water quality as long as the overall water quality is
maintained in a region. Objective A1 must also be met. Maintaining or improving the overall quality of fresh water within a region means that water quality cannot be allowed to decline in one part of a region without equally improving it elsewhere. If a freshwater objective is set that allows for degradation from the current state, it must be offset by objectives to achieve a commensurate improvement within the region.

[Emphasis added]

"Offsets". Its like climate change all over again. But unlike tons of carbon dioxide-equivalent, rivers aren't simply interchangeable. Unless you think of them simply as supplies of water for cows, rather than as individual ecosystems.

I'm still waiting for a copy of the judgement to appear on NZLII, but the Court apparently ruled that deliberately allowing water quality to decline was contrary to the purposes of the RMA. The implication for the government's approach in the National Policy Statement - and its underlying desire to trash our lakes, rivers and streams for the benefit of the dairy industry - should be obvious.

Member's Day

Today is a Member's Day. And the big question is what will the parties do in expectation of the shift in the balance of power when the Northland by-election results are finalised? Will they filibuster to prevent ballots or preserve business for when it is winnable, or try and whip through to get rid of it quickly / open space for more?

Today provides plenty of scope for filibustering, with a pair of second readings for private and local bills, followed by the committee stage of Tracey Martin's Social Security (Clothing Allowances for Orphans and Unsupported Children) Amendment Bill. A party which wanted to talk things out could use up the entire day on these. But if they want to push on, there's the first readings of Damien O'Connor's Underground Coal Mining Safety Bill, Iain Lees-Galloway's Electoral (Adjustment of Thresholds) Amendment Bill, and Winston Peters' SuperGold Health Check Bill. And if they start any of those first readings, there will be a ballot tomorrow.

New bills for the ballot include Catherine Delahunty's Public Works (Prohibition of Compulsory Acquisition of Māori Land) Amendment Bill and Jenny Salesa's Employment Relations (Restoring Kiwis' Right to a Break at Work) Amendment Bill, both of which do what they say on the label. There's still no sign of Winston's promised anti-name suppression bill, and now he has won Northland, he may feel that he doesn't need the excuse.