Thursday, November 19, 2026

Repealing pay equity breached the BORA

Last year, the regime rammed through the Equal Pay Amendment Act under urgency, gutting pay equity laws, dumping all claims, and stealing $13 billion from New Zealand women. Today, the High Court ruled that their law discriminated against women and violated the Bill of Rights Act:
The Government breached women's rights when it scrapped dozens of pay equity claims and made it harder to apply in future, the High Court has ruled.

In his judgment, Justice Paul Radich said the coalition's tightening of the Equal Pay Act discriminated against women and was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

Radich also said the changes had been driven mainly by a desire to save money, rather than to fix a broken system.

This is the second declaration of inconsistency the regime has received for its laws this term (they've also been issued one for their gang-patch ban). And we're still waiting for one on voter suppression. Plus of course there's prisoner voting, which parliament fixed in response to a declaration, only for National to say "fuck the courts" and reinstate a law which had been found explicitly to violate the BORA, and the voting age, which National refused to do anything about.

...which means that the chances of the regime doing the right thing and repealing their discriminatory law are not good. They are on record as being an explicitly anti-constitutional regime (and that's not even looking at their assault on te Tiriti). Which means that whether this gets fixed depends entirely on the election result.

This is no way to run a government. We have a Bill of Rights Act for a reason, and if a government can piss all over it while laughing drunkenly, then we need to look at doing something about it. The BORA assigned Parliament the role of being ultimate arbiter of our human rights, on the basis that they were good chaps and would ultimately do the right thing, or at least provide reasons where they diverged from the law. That has proven to be utterly false. Parliament has been a terrible guardian of our human rights, and the current regime seems to revel in breaching them. They are clearly both unwilling and incapable of performing the duty assigned to them, and that means we should take the job off them and give it to someone who can and more importantly will do it: the courts. If this government has taught us anything, it is that the BORA needs to be supreme, to keep the politicians on a tighter leash.