Monday, November 16, 2026

We can't trust politicians to reform the electoral system

Newsroom reports that a group of eminent electoral experts are calling for a select committee inquiry into MMP to tweak the system and preserve proportionality. But while I agree with the goal - this is clearly something we need to do - a select committee inquiry is entirely the wrong vehicle.

Why? For the obvious reasons: select committees are comprised of politicians. Who have shown repeatedly that they can not be trusted to get their grubby paws in the electoral system.

This goes all the way back to when MMP was established: the Royal Commission on the Electoral System recommended a 4% threshold, but the established parties wanted to make it as difficult as possible for others to challenge their duopoly, so arbitrarily raised it to 5%. The 2012 review of MMP made a bunch of recommendations, and the politicians cheery-picked and bickered and cross-vetoed, trying to rig the system for themselves and their allies, with the result that they ultimately couldn't agree on any of them - which is fortunate, because the overall package would have resulted in a less proportional parliament and a greater two-party duopoly. The 2023 review made similar recommendations (plus Labour's fantasy of a four year term for less accountability), fortunately with a similar result.

So, having the politicians as first reviewers is a guarantee of a partisan, politicised outcome, favouring the government of the day, because the political class can't help but be venal, selfish pricks.

What's the alternative? Neutral, independent experts, of course. They're more likely to reach a neutral conclusion not aimed at anyone's electoral advantage or disadvantage. And that's what we need.

Unfortunately, we need politicians to pass laws, so they'll still get to have their say. But it won't be the first say, setting the default terms of change. And if experts come up with a proposal, and the politicians depart from it, their solution - and them - will be immediately delegitimised, and they'll have to spend all their time defending it against us. Which is where we want them.

And of course this is predicated on only needing small tweaks - a bigger parliament to make overhangs less relevant, which will grow with the electorates to preserve proportionality (at least until major party weakness takes them below 50%). If we need bigger changes, then even independent experts aren't enough. For legitimacy for that, we'll need to start with a citizen's jury.