Wednesday, October 11, 2006



Comparing emissions growth

Nick Smith is nothing if not reliable. Every time he speaks on climate change - at the climate change and policy symposium, or in Question Time today, he trots out the same statistic to illustrate the failure of New Zealand climate change policy: that

New Zealand emissions have grown at four times the rate of the United States and three times the rate of Australia

Now, while New Zealand emissions have grown catastrophically (primarily due to the complete failure of this and previous governments to actually do anything to curb them or encourage sink creation), and are nothing to be proud of, I cannot for the life of me see where Smith is getting his numbers from. The UNFCCC secretariat's compilation of key GHG data [PDF, large] gives the following rates of growth in emissions between 1990 and 2003:

New Zealand gross: 22.5%
Australia gross: 23.3%
US gross: 13.3%

New Zealand net: 30.7%
Australia net: 4.9%
US net: 20.3%

So, looking at gross emissions, ours have grown by slightly less than Australia's, and 50% faster than the US's. Looking at net emissions (which is the measure that actually matters under Kyoto), ours have still grown 50% faster than the US's, but a massive six times faster than Australia's (see what happens if you pay people to plant trees?). Either way, our performance is dismal, but it still doesn't add up to what Smith says it does.

Fresh python

Terry Jones - A splendid achievement

Tuesday, October 10, 2006



United Future and climate change

I've been playing phone tag for the last day with United Future, trying to get some comment out of them on National's abrubt about-face on climate change and their support for a limited emissions trading regime. Unfortunately, United Future doesn't have anything to say yet. However, they are putting together "a comprehensive response" which will be out in a couple of days. Watch this space, I guess.

Meanwhile, the government's reaction to National's new desire to reduce emissions may become clearer in Question Time today:

NANDOR TANCZOS to the Minister responsible for Climate Change Issues: Does he stand by his statement that “There is a growing sense of urgency among governments … that action needs to be taken now” on climate change; if so, why won’t the Government consider putting in place price-based measures across the economy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions before 2012?

It will be interesting to see what their answer will be.

"A joint criminal enterprise"

Scott Horton has an excellent post at Balkinization on the subject of When Lawyers Are War Criminals. He points out that at the end of World War Two, lawyers working for the Nazi regime were put on trial for, among other things, their role in drafting and implementing "night and fog" decree, which authorised the disappearance, detention, torture and murder of those deemed to oppose the Nazis in occupied countries. This was a violation of international law at the time (specifically, the Hague Convention of 1907 and the 1929 Geneva Convention), but those instruments were dismissed as "quaint" and reflecting "outmoded notions of chivalric warfare". Two top lawyers of the German Justice Department were eventually convicted of crimes against humanity and war crimes for crafting this policy, and sentenced to ten years imprisonment; essentially, the precedent is that

cute lawyerly evasions and gimmicks, so commonly indulged in other areas of the law, will not be tolerated on fundamental questions of law of armed conflict relating to the protection of civilians and detainees. In other words, lawyers are not permitted to get it wrong.

The application to the Bush Administration and its policies of rendition, torture, and the systematic denial of Geneva Convention rights to detainees is obvious: top administration policymakers, including Attorney-General Alberto Gonzales, Vice-Presidential Chief of Staff David Addington, and lawyers John Yoo and Jay Bybee are in the gun for war crimes. As for their recent effort to provide retroactive immunity from prosecution for those crimes under US law, Horton has this to say:

The initial draft makes clear that the White House sought impunity for crimes arising as a result of the use of three techniques that the Bush Administration (and, from the remarkable working of one of Bush's press conferences, Bush himself) authorized and which constitute grave breaches under Common Article 3: waterboarding, long-time standing (or as it was called by its NKVD inventors, in Russian: stoika) and hypothermia or cold cell. The use of these techniques is a criminal act. The purported authorization of these techniques is a criminal act. The larger effort to employ them constitutes a joint criminal enterprise.

[...]

If the consequence of the Act is to immunize those who authorized these techniques from prosecution, is that lawful? The US position, articulated most recently in connection with Yugoslavia's efforts to immunize its military leaders, was that any such act would only provide evidence of a broader conspiracy to commit war crimes. Consequently, the grant of immunity is ineffective in the contemplation of the international community; moreover, those involved in purporting to grant immunity may thereby be roped into a charged joint criminal enterprise.

The message to lawyers ought to be clear: if the Bush Administration asks you to find a way around international law so they can torture people, run. Otherwise, you may one day be held to account for your involvement by a country which claims universal jurisdiction for war crimes.

[Hat tip: Talk Left]

New Fisk

Why peace treaties don't travel very well

Guest column: 10/10: a Catholic view on the death penalty

By Muerk

On July 5 1902 in Italy an eleven year old girl was viciously attacked by a family friend. The little girl, Maria Goretti, resisted the attempted rape by twenty year old Alessandro Serenelli and in his rage he stabbed her fourteen times. Maria Goretti died in hospital the next day.

Serenelli was the type of criminal that many would like to see given the death penalty. Some would say that his crime was unforgivable, especially given that Serenelli was unrepentant. But before Maria died she was asked if she forgave him, she replied, "Yes, for the love of Jesus I forgive him... and I want him to be with me in Paradise."

Serenelli was sentenced to thirty years in jail, but if he had been given the death penalty our story could possibly have ended here as just another tragic story of brutal violence. Society could have felt complacent knowing that whilst the wrongs Maria suffered had not been righted, they had been punished. Revenge would have been satisfied by the murderer's death.

However, thankfully this story is not over. After serving seven years in jail Alessandro Serenelli had a vision of his victim.

He saw a garden. where a young girl, dressed in white, was gathering lilies. She smiled, and came near him, and encouraged him to accept an armful of the lilies. As he accepted them, each lily transformed into a still white flame. Maria then disappeared.

This was enough to convert Serenelli and after twenty-seven years in prison the first thing he did when released was to go and visit Maria's mother and beg her forgiveness. In 1950 along with her mother he was present at Saint Maria Goretti's canonisation. The Catholic Church believes that St Maria's final wish for Alessandro to be with her in Heaven is achievable. Anyone can repent and be forgiven, even those who have committed the gravest of deeds. But in order for that to happen people have to be left alive. All human life is precious, even someone like Alessandro, and no one has the right to end another person's life even to atone for murder.

10/10: World Day Against the Death Penalty

Today, October 10th, is the world day against the death penalty. Last year, at least 2,148 people were executed in 22 countries (figures courtesy of Amnesty International). That's 2,148 too many. Judicial murder is an abomination which can never be justified, and it is something we should speak out against. The world day against the death penalty is the day we do that.

This year's theme is "The Death Penalty: a Failure of Justice", highlighting the fact that the death penalty is often applied in an unfair and discriminatory manner, and that sometimes the innocent are executed. One example of this from New Zealand is Hamiora Pere, the only person executed in New Zealand for treason, who was executed because the government "needed someone to hang" in the wake of Te Kooti's war. On the innocence front, doubts have been raised about Minnie Dean, and even Walter James Bolton, the last man executed in New Zealand. Far more troubling is the record from the US: since 1973, 123 people have been released from death row in America after being exonerated. And they were the lucky ones; Texas seems to have executed an innocent man in 2004, and we really have no idea how many other innocent people have been murdered by the US system due to police or prosecutorial misconduct, unreliable evidence, or inadequate representation. Even if you think judicial murder can be morally justified, this ought to give pause. No system of justice is perfect, and abuse of power, simple fallibility, and the potential for injustice ought to rule out capital punishment. Someone imprisoned unjustly can be freed, but death is final, and not forgiving of mistakes.

Fortunately, we seem to be slowly winning the argument. Two countries have formally abolished the death penalty in the last year: Mexico and the Philippines. Hopefully we'll be able to add Morocco to that list next year.

Interesting and topical

Last month's Atlantic Monthly had an interesting piece by Robert Kaplan on North Korea. Not on the prospects for war on the Korean peninsula (the Atlantic has done that before, here, and its not pretty), but on what will happen when (when?) the North Korean regime collapses. It's subscriber-only, but The Marmot's Hole has been kind enough to post a copy here.

Monday, October 09, 2006



Sharpening the mind

Something I missed while down in Wellington: currently, Palmerston North City Council has crawled into bed with Mighty River Power in an effort to develop a windfarm on a city reserve behind Massey University. It's a deeply unpopular move (though not quite as unpopular as the Regional Council deciding the Manawatu River should be Fonterra's sewer), and submissions at the recent public hearings on the plan have been overwhelmingly negative. And now it finally seems to be sinking in to some on the city council. Despite the fact that the issue under discussion at this stage is the narrow question of whether the reserve's purpose and management plan should be changed to allow renewable electricity generation, rather than whether there will be a wind farm, the chair of the committee hearing the issue has come to the same conclusion as the public: that the two issues are inseparable, at least politically:

Cr Claridge says the real arguments that people are most interested in, such as how many wind turbines, where they will be and what damage they will do, will pass to hearings under the Resource Management Act under an independent commissioner and that seems wrong.

"A lot of councillors now have serious concerns about the whole matter. I don't think, myself, that we can leave it to the resource consent process.

"We, as politicians, will be held to account. The general feeling in council is we have responsibility for it."

It's just amazing how upcoming local body elections can sharpen the mind. Now we just have to hope that the fear of being held to account by the public at the ballot box will sharpen it more than Mighty River's frankly corrupt offer of cash to the city council in exchange for the reserve's purpose being changed...

They did it

North Korea claims to have tested a nuclear weapon.

I admit it, I'm scared - not so much over the North Koreans (despite allegations to the contrary, they're not mad - just very, very insecure), but the berserk response this could provoke from the US. Or from Japan's new nationalist Prime Minister. The last thing I want to see is Japan abandoning its pacifist constitution and opposition to nuclear weapons to get itself an independent deterrant.

On the plus side, this means Iran is probably no longer in the crosshairs.

Finally

Parliament returns from recess this week, for a three week sitting. Finally! Something to blog about! Tomorrow I expect the government will introduce its Criminal proceeds (Recovery) Bill, which has been hanging around in the ether for the last month. Wednesday is a Member's Day, which will see a vote on the second reading of the Manukau City Council (Control of Street Prostitution) Bill (which should be interesting). Thursday will see the release of the Auditor-General's report into the misuse of Parliamentary Services funds, and almost certainly a debate on it, despite National's claim to the contrary. Beyond that, according to the sitting programme, there are only seven more sitting weeks (and three Member's Days) until christmas.

It will be interesting to see whether the mudslinging and poisonous atmosphere which prevailed before the recess will carry over, or whether our MPs will behave themselves. Unfortunately, I expect the worst.

Pure hypocrisy

National is accusing Labour of leaking the Auditor-General's report into the misuse of Parliamentary Services spending [audio] in order to "soften up the public" to its conclusions. Even assuming its true (the Sunday Star-Times piece in question seemed to be mostly speculation - hell, they even asked DPF for his opinion), for the past few months, National has been accusing the government of corruption based on... a leaked draft of the same report. So it's apparantly OK for them to leak to influence public opinion, but not for other people to do it. This is pure hypocrisy, and yet another example of National's "one law for all, for everyone but National" position.

New Fisk

The Age of Terror

Climate change symposium: the morning

On Friday I attended the Climate Change: the Policy Challenges Symposium in Wellington. The symposium was organised by VUW's Institute of Policy Studies as a followup to the Climate Change and Governance Conference earlier in the year, and brought together by New Zealand and international speakers to discuss specifically policy rather than the broader questions discussed at the earlier event. I've already covered the keynote speeches of David Parker and Nick Smith, but here's a rundown of the rest of the morning session:

Professor Jonathan Boston (VUW) opened the symposium, highlighting some of the recent evidence of climate change and lamenting the fact that most of it went unreported in the New Zealand media. As a result, the debate in New Zealand is still stuck on whether climate change is happening, where most of the rest of the world has moved on to what we are going to do about it. He also noted the scale of the problem we face: to avoid a temperature rise of 2 degrees Celsius over preindustrial levels (now widely accepted as the threshold for "dangerous" levels of anthropogenic climate change under the UNFCCC), we need to stabilize equivalent CO2 concentrations at no more than 450 parts per million (which means about 400 ppm of CO2). But we're already at 385 ppm CO2, and around 420ppm CO2-equivalent. If we are to avoid breaching that cap, developed countries will need to reduce emissions by between 70% and 90% by 2050 - and more the longer we delay.

Professor Michael Grubb (Chief Economist, The Carbon Trust) gave a good, chunky presentation on "climate change solutions in theory and practice: national and international dimensions". The first part of the talk looked at the general analytic framework of climate change policy, which recommends some combination of energy efficiency, economic instruments, and technology as a solution. Unsurprisingly he concluded that each has its own strengths for targeting particular sources of emissions, and that all three were needed for comprehensive policy.

The Carbon Trust has done a lot of work on mapping sources of emissions by sector in an effort to work out the coverage of current policy and where future policy should best be targeted. One of their interesting results (from this report [PDF] is presented below:

This tracks UK business emissions by sector, their source, and the number of entities in that group; total emissions are represented by area. It is immediately apparent that the orange parts of the graph - representing emissions from buildings (either direct heating from coal and gas, or electrical load for heating, lighting, computers etc) make up a large portion of emissions. But policy is primarily targeted at the blue bits, and primarily in the large energy-intensive industries sector via the European Emissions Trading Scheme. The large proportion of emissions from buildings is only weakly targeted, and so potential for reduction is unrealised, despite the fact that huge gains (at least 15%) are cost-effective. One of the Carbon Trust's jobs is to find ways of realising this potential, and to break down the barriers to uptake (which mostly seem to be systematic and behavioural rather than economic).

He then moved on to discuss the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) - an emissions market covering 46% of the EU's greenhouse gas emissions. He noted that there have been major problems with overallocation, which have affected pricing, and that "grandparenting" of permits in the electricity sector had resulted in their making windfall profits which had undermined confidence in the scheme (the price of electricity went up to reflect the added cost of carbon, but generators had been given the permits for free, so they collected the increased price and laughed all the way to the bank). Effectively the ETS had turned into a massive rent-grab as governments and industries fought over who would capture the revenue from carbon prices. Grubb was fairly sanguine about this - its what politics is all about, after all - but at the same time clearly hoped that some of that rent-stream could be put to use by governments to push the technological innovation needed to move towards a lower-carbon future.

Grubb will be speaking again on the same topic on the 18th at the School of Government in Wellington, if anyone is interested. Details here.

Dr Steve Hatfield-Dodds (CSIRO) spoke on "building climate policy momentum through improving incentive alignment". His key idea was that "economic culture" (of which he is highly critical) impedes a public policy response, and encourages three misconceptions about dealing with climate change: that it will require lower living standards; that it will result in increased energy prices, and less affordable electricity, and therefore "hurt the poor"; and that delaying action can reduce costs. On the first misconception, he expanded on the talk he gave last time, arguing that economic growth and living standards will continue to increase even with extremely harsh climate change policy, and that the difference it makes is that it will take 52 years rather than 50 for incomes to double. He also rehashed previous material about the asymmetry between willingness-to-pay and willingness-to-accept, and added some empirical data (reported (badly) here) showing that framing policy in terms of costs rather than "you'll simply benefit less" results in a 15% reduction in support.

On the second misconception, he presented modelling results from ABARE (the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics) showing that while energy prices will rise, they will still rise much slower than incomes, meaning that affordability does not decline. He also pointed out that there is significant potential for revenue recycling - and conversely, that insulating sectors of the economy against the full cost of their emissions costs us all.

On the merits of delayed action, there is a strong and reasonable presumption that technology costs will decline over time. But Hatfield-Dodds points out that the argument for delayed action rests on a hidden assumption that timing doesn't matter, and that differences in emissions pathways doesn't materially affect the outcome. This is something climate scientists are not at all sure about, and its not something we can afford to be wrong about. Risk management suggests therefore that we should act early rather than later, on the grounds that this will both ensure that that technology does arrive (something economists just blithely ignore), and that we don't commit to shooting ourselves in the foot.

Finally, he talked a little about the international situation and the problems it presents. Under the "Kyoto model" of constrained and unconstrained emissions zones (i.e. "Annex I" and "non-Annex I" countries), "leakage" is a problem, in that emitters can escape the cost of policy by moving to the unconstrained zone. But a commitment by key players such as China and India that they will move to constrain emissions at some stage in the future (even if they don't say exactly when) will effectively plug that leak. Getting such a commitment (or ideally a timeframe or criteria for key non-Annex I parties such as China, India and Brazil to move towards Annex I) should be a key goal of current negotiations on a post-Kyoto regime.

Dr Tim Denne (Covec Consultency) spoke on "achieving emission reductions at least cost: international lessons for the New Zealand context". He began by pointing out the bleak facts about our continued growth in emissions, and looking at some overseas success stories of emissions reduction. Germany had reduced their emissions by reducing the use of lignite and by the post-unification collapse of the East German economy. Luxembourg had shifted its industries from using coal to using imported electricity, effectively exporting its emissions to other countries in the EU. The UK had been highly successful switching from coal to gas, while France had increased its reliance on nuclear power and reduced agricultural emissions by reducing cattle numbers (though this seems to be primarily due to reduced subsidies rather than any effect of climate change policy). Transport emissions had increased in every country, primarily due to increased demand. The lesson here is that the most significant reductions seem to come from fuel switching, while agricultural and transport emissions seem very difficult to reduce unless you are willing to shoot cows and throw them in a ditch (or, less wastefully, eat them). Unfortunately, there is only limited scope for fuel switching in New Zealand (and due to limited gas supplies, we seem to be going the other way at the moment), while our geography and the fact that we are an agricultural nation compounds the problems for transport and agriculture. This means that we are going to have to rely on emissions trading (buying reductions elsewhere) rather than being able to reduce emissions domestically.

A key question posed was "should transport and agriculture pay?" Denne thought they should, as even a modest charge encourages emitters to look around for solutions. It also avoids any question of subsidising output (an issue we may face over the government's decision to cover agricultural emissions - an enormous environmental subsidy and wealth transfer to farmers). So fundamentally a "fart tax" or agricultural emissions levy is a good instrument. He echoed Steve Hatfield-Dodds in arguing that insulating some sectors costs us all, and presented some figures comparing the cost of agricultural emissions with the cost of a 1% shift in various tax brackets. By my BOTE calculations, the cost of covering the emissions from farmer's sacred cows would handily pay for a 3% cut in the business and middle personal tax rates. Maybe we should all remember that next time they drive a tractor up Parliament's steps demanding that we subsidise their pollution...

More controversially, Denne raised the possibility of economic collapse (a term deliberately chosen to be provocative). Why not kill Huntly, or shut down polluting industries? Leakage is clearly an issue, as are social impacts such as unemployment - but the risk posed by the former seems to be overstated when you consider that the places emissions might leak to will be part of the system eventually, meaning that leakers probably won't be escaping the cost of emissions after all. Social impacts are an issue, but he didn't think the concept should be dismissed so readily (and as an obvious point, the savings from reduced emissions could be used to compensate the losers).

Finally, Denne stressed the need for all emitters to face the international cost of carbon in the long run, and that we need to get a price signal working before 2012 if we are to avoid regrets with long-lived infrastructure (such as power stations and housing). Unfortunately I'm not sure that the government is heading in the right direction on this...

I'll do the afternoon session in another post.

Sunday, October 08, 2006



War on the wharves

I visited the Museum of Wellington City & Sea today to see the exhibition 1913 Strike: War on the Wharves. While all but forgotten today, the Great Strike of 1913 had an enormous impact on New Zealand at the time, and saw social disorder and rioting even more severe than the 1981 Springbok Tour. In response to the waterfront workers going on strike, the newly-elected government of "Farmer Bill" Massey recruited farmers from the provinces as "special constables" and armed them in an attempt to open the wharves by force. For eight weeks, "Massey's cossacks" battled with striking workers in the streets, until the strike finally ended. It is probably the closest to revolution we have ever come in this country.

While the strikers lost the battle, they came a lot closer to winning the war. Eight strike leaders were arrested, four of them - Tom Barker, William Young, Harry Holland, and Bob Semple - for sedition (Peter Fraser was also imprisoned for inciting a breach of the peace). As you might be able to tell from some of those names, the leaders of the strike went on to form the core of the Labour Party, and two of them - Michael Joseph Savage and Peter Fraser - went on to become Prime Minister. Unfortunately, that didn't stop a repeat in 1951, under much the same circumstances...

The exhibition itself is fairly small, but concisely tells the story of the war on the wharves from beginning to end. It also includes two lists - one of those workers who stayed loyal throughout the strike, and a list of shame of those who served as special constables. For those who know their family history, it might be interesting to see which list your relatives appear on.

Saturday, October 07, 2006



Waterboarding is a war crime

Or at least it is when done to Americans, according to the US military:

[I]n 1947, the United States charged a Japanese officer, Yukio Asano, with war crimes for carrying out another form of waterboarding on a U.S. civilian. The subject was strapped on a stretcher that was tilted so that his feet were in the air and head near the floor, and small amounts of water were poured over his face, leaving him gasping for air until he agreed to talk.

"Asano was sentenced to 15 years of hard labor," Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.) told his colleagues last Thursday during the debate on military commissions legislation. "We punished people with 15 years of hard labor when waterboarding was used against Americans in World War II," he said.

And just to be clear, this is exactly the same method of waterboarding used by US torturers. Unfortunately, the US has just passed a law granting those torturers an amnesty for their crimes. So much for Justice Jackson's statement at Nuremberg that "we [the United States government] are not prepared to lay down a rule of criminal conduct against others which we would not be willing to have invoked against us"...

[Hat tip: Talk Left]

Friday, October 06, 2006



Climate change symposium: stealing a march

Today I attended the Climate Change: the Policy Challenges Symposium in Wellington. I'll post on the wonkery later, but in this one I'll do the highlights: David Parker and Nick Smith.

Climate Change Minister David Parker was the first speaker, having had his talk on The way forward on climate change moved forward by six hours to pre-empt National's policy announcement later in the day. Unfortunately, the timing didn't hide the fact that it was absolutely underwhelming. I'd been expecting Parker to make use of the excellent platform provided by the policy symposium to announce some policy of his own. Instead, in keeping with the government's (too) cautious post-carbon tax approach, he "announced" a list of "strategic principles" so obvious as to be practically banal:

  1. Recognising that while action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions will have moderate costs, the predicted costs and risks of inaction are unacceptably high
  2. Recognising that effective international action is needed to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions, New Zealand should help by reducing its own emissions, and by encouraging other countries to act.
  3. Recognising that New Zealand's response should maximise the economic advantages of using energy and resources more efficiently.
  4. Agreeing that our response should start with the most easily-achieved and least-cost solutions.
  5. Agreeing that a combination of sectoral and economy-wide measures, including voluntary, price-based and regulatory measures, is likely to be needed, and
  6. Agreeing that all sectors of the economy should play an equitable part in the nation's response to climate change, reflecting the fact that some sectors are able to achieve emissions reductions more easily than others. It's important to consider there are sectors in which there are few low-emissions technologies available at reasonable cost.

Or, in English, "we should do something, and it should be cheap and practical". This is the sort of thing Cabinet agrees at the earliest stages of the policy development process, before it starts looking at actual policy (or even options for actual policy). And if this is where the government is at the moment, then we're pretty much back where we were in early 2000 (and early 1998, and early 1992). In other words, nowhere.

Actually, that's not quite fair on Parker. The government does have policies(the biofuels obligation, for example), and they are clearly headed in the right direction (albeit slowly). But what they mostly have at the moment is a lot of fiddling around the edges, with little in the way of core policy to produce emissions reduction or sink absorption. It is a sign of the emptiness at the heart of government policy that a) they're forced to refer to a "12-page list of government initiatives already underway" (attached here) in the hope that the public will accept "quantity over quality"; and b) the most important announcement Parker could make today was the establishment of a "Climate Change Advisory Panel".

Which brings me to National's Nick Smith. Where Parker was tepid and underwhelming, Smith was the opposite. The National Party has had its conversion on the road to Kyoto, and they want everyone to know it. Quite apart from their credibility problem, the chutzpah is astounding. Having spent the last six years trying to deny the reality of climate change, they now admit that the case is strong, "[the] uncertainties are not an excuse for doing nothing", and that the risks must be managed. Having railed against Labour's decision to ratify the Kyoto Protocol, they now support participation because it is the only way to get larger countries to act. And having done everything possible to undermine the carbon tax and "fart" tax (including driving a tractor up the steps of Parliament), they are now criticising the government for abandoning those policies. About the only thing missing was the statement that Oceania has always been at war with East Asia.

As for their policy, its a marvellous piece of political ju-jitsu. The ultimate destination of government policy has been fairly clear for the last six months or so: some form of limited carbon tax or pilot emissions trading scheme applying to the energy sector and possibly large industrial emitters as a precursor to full emissions trading post 2012; vehicle fuel efficiency standards or a "feebate" scheme, a biofuels obligation, a backdown on the disastrous deforestation cap, and more agricultural R&D. So, National has basically stolen those policies - and a march on the government - announcing support for energy-sector emissions trading "immediately", a feebate scheme to boost vehicle efficiency, biofuels, an end to the deforestation cap, and more agricultural R&D. About the only point of difference is that National favours gutting the RMA "to promote renewable energy". And now they're "hop[ing] the government will steal their ideas".

So now it seems that we have a convergence of climate change policy between the two main parties. Unfortunately, this means that action is probably even further away than ever. Quite apart from the fact that Labour will probably shift its policies to try and create a point of difference with National (throwing their careful process of policy development into disarray), there's also the fact that real action on climate change seems to be a line in the sand for Peter Dunne, while Winston opposes any policy which might raise electricity prices for pensioners. So even if Labour wanted to call National's bluff and use their announcement to put a limited cap and trade regime in place before the start of CP1, they probably couldn't. Which is, I suspect, National's point.

Busy

I'm busy today attending the Climate Change: the Policy Challenges Symposium in Wellington, so no bloggage today. I might put together some posts about the symposium over the weekend.

Thursday, October 05, 2006



No surprise

DPF is crowing that the latest UN Security Council straw poll suggests South Korean Foreign Minister Ban Ki-moon will be the next Secretary-General - so there'll be no promotion for Helen Clark. But is this really a surprise? After all, there's been no evidence at all she was ever pursuing the job - only speculation. And who's been feeding that speculation at every opportunity? That's right - the National Party...

Going Green?

There's a pair of interesting opinion pieces, one from Colin James in the Business Herald (offline, but up here in a day or two), and the other from Vernon Small in the Dominion-Post, suggesting that National is about to reverse its long-standing opposition to the Kyoto Protocol and action on climate change as part of a broader effort to "go green". This is welcome; National accepting that there is in fact a problem will make it that much easier for the government to pursue solutions, and a British-style environmental bidding-war between the major parties can only be good for the environment as a whole. At the same time, I think National has a bit of a credibility problem here, in that they are led by an outright climate change denier. And even if Don Brash publicly recanted that position while emerging from a screening of "An Inconvenient Truth" and carrying a copy of The Weather Makers, would anyone really believe him? Or would they think (based on his demonstrated lack of integrity and his belief in "a moral obligation to lie") that he was simply saying whatever he thought would get him elected, and that his environmental promises would quietly be forgotten the moment he gained power in favour of the singlemined pursuit of tax cuts for the rich? My money is on the latter.