Sunday, October 15, 2006
Climate change symposium: the afternoon I
Last Friday I attended the one-day Climate Change: the Policy Challenges Symposium in Wellington. Where the morning session focused mainly on the international context, the afternoon dealt specifically with domestic policy:
Dr Bert Metz (IPCC / Netherlands Environmental Agency) spoke on "How to avoid more than two degrees of warming?" The EU has adopted a target (based on the UNFCCC's objective of avoiding "dangerous" anthropogenic climate change) of limiting climate change to a 2 degree increase in average global temperature. Unfortunately its difficult to tell how much CO2 this allows us to emit; the best guess is that to have an even chance of staying within the target, the global concentration of greenhouse gases needs to be limited to around 450 ppm CO2-equivalent (or 400 ppm of CO2). But the CO2 concentration is at 380 ppm now, so this will be a very challenging target. Achieving it will require around a 50% reduction in emissions by 2050, and 70% or more by 2100 (figures relative to today; the cuts are deeper compared with the "business as usual" baseline). That looks insurmountable, but there are plenty of reduction options available, and a fair amount of choice in how we achieve it. However, the core of any lower-emissions pathway is likely to involve massive changes in the global energy system, with vastly reduced use of oil and coal and corresponding increases in biofuels and nuclear or renewable energy (note that all of these options exist now, so its not as if we can't do anything about it). There's also the interesting possibility of linking carbon capture and sequestration technology (if developed and commercialised) to biofuel generation to effectively suck CO2 out of the atmosphere and start reversing the damage we have caused; this has the potential to significantly lower both the cost of abatement and the risk of dangerous temperature rise.
The next section, on "Policy Issues and Options", consisted of four short talks by people involved in one way or another with the policy community.
Phil Gurnsey (Ministry for the Environment) is the man currently responsible for climate change policy. His talk on "The Policy Landscape" covered the enormous shift we have seen in international opinion in the last few year, the growing global consensus that we actually have to do something about the problem, and the driving forces behind New Zealand policy. As a public servant, he couldn't really say much, but he did highlight some of the upcoming policy announcements and suggested in a roundabout way that the government was looking at a gradual introduction of emissions trading.
Murray Ward, Gurnsey's predecessor between 1996 and 2002 (and thus the man responsible for both the 1999 emissions trading scheme and the now-discarded carbon tax) talked about "An Integrated Approach". He pointed out that from the 1st of January 2008 - a little over a year away - New Zealand would be fully exposed to the international cost of carbon, and that every ton of CO2-equivalent emitted that could otherwise have been avoided will cost the taxpayer between $20 - 40. He argued strongly that this cost needs to be reflected in the domestic cost of energy, and that an effective response to climate change was impossible unless this occurred (mostly because we would repeat the same mistake we made between 1997 and today: allowing major new capital investments to occur in the energy sector which will burden us with costs for years to come - e.g. Marsden B). However, he also noted that this raised some equity considerations, which suggested a need for both a separate track for "competitiveness at risk" firms which could not pass on their costs, and "smart revenue recycling" to compensate and assist groups that are disproportionately affected. Having established the general bases, he proposed... a quick and dirty energy-sector emissions trading system, using Kyoto Assigned Amount Units so that it was fully interfaced with the international market. The government would auction an appropriate amount of AAU, while requiring the energy sector to provide it with AAU to cover their emissions, and the market would handle the rest. The revenue from the auction - estimated at $1.5 billion over 5 years - would be recycled into research, further emissions reduction (planting trees), providing information, training and capital to assist with energy efficiency, and helping those significantly disadvantaged (primarily by aiming to lower their energy bills through e.g. installing insulation), as well as a "carbon fund" to help pay for future impacts of climate change (floods and droughts). The emissions trading regime would be supplemented by a projects mechanism similar to the existing one, in order to spread the opportunity cost of emissions across the economy.
This is a good policy, particularly with the emphasis on revenue recycling. One of the failures of the carbon tax was that it was able to be presented as a tax grab by the opposition - with some justification as the money went into the consolidated fund rather than being tagged for any purpose (Treasury hates tagged revenue). And while the government proposed some recycling, it was never made explicit and in any case was not into the right areas (better depreciation rates to encourage capital upgrades rather than explicitly seeking environmental double dividends). Making it clear that any revenue will go straight back into helping solve the problem - and into helping those specifically disadvantaged by it - would do a lot to build public support and reduce opposition.
Peter Neilson (Business Council for Sustainable Development) spoke on "Price-Based Mechanisms". He made the by-now standard argument that we need a price on emissions to shift investment patterns away from carbon-intensive technologies and towards lower-carbon ones. The carbon tax was one attempt at this, but it failed because "the case for doing something about climate change was not widely appreciated" (whereas it is now), it exempted agriculture (our biggest emitter), and was seen as a revenue grab (see above). Unfortunately, it is unlikely to be revived, as too many parties are now on record as opposing it. Instead, we are now likely to see an emissions trading scheme. Neilson's contribution to this was to suggest grandparenting for "competitiveness at risk" firms, and using that promise to demand firms start monitoring their emissions now in the hope that it might get them to notice their activities. He was also strongly in favour of linking any system directly to the international market, on the basis that Kyoto (and whatever succeeds it) isn't just about lowering New Zealand's emissions, but also about New Zealand doing its share to lower global emissions.
Dr Charlotte Severne (NIWA) spoke on "The M?ori Economy". This is based heavily on primary production - farming, fishing, and forestry - and so will be heavily affected by climate change. At the same time, Maori organisations have a lower ability to plan for and respond to climate change, both because of less access to capital, and lack of capacity. But despite facing a higher burden, Maori have not generally been included in the process of formulating climate change policy. As she pointed out, those attending the symposium were overwhelmingly Pakeha.
That's the crunchy bit; I'll do the rest of the afternoon in another post. In the meantime, the presentations from the symposium are now online here, and they're well worth checking out.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/15/2006 01:31:00 AM
4
comments
Labels:
Climate Change,
Event Reports
Saturday, October 14, 2006
Protesting Fonterra
I went on a protest march today. About 200 people turned out to protest against Fonterra and the Palmerston North City Council using the Manawatu River as a sewer. While it doesn't sound like many, that's pretty good for Palmerston North, and it suggests that the environment may be a serious issue in next year's local body elections. Hopefully the Greens will manage to find a candidate or two to tap into that constituency.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/14/2006 08:34:00 PM
0
comments
Labels:
Dirty Dairying,
Environment,
Local Government,
Protests
And the Nobel Peace Prize goes to...
The Grameen Bank rather than John Bolton? Clearly the Nobel Committee have been infiltrated by anti-American communists!
Jokes aside, the Grameen Bank are a worthy recipient. For those who haven't heard of them, they run a microcredit scheme in Bangladesh focusing on poor rural women, and aimed at helping them lift themselves out of poverty. A typical project involves loaning a poor widow the money to buy a cellphone; she sells calls to other people in her village, allowing her to repay the loan, feed her family, and send her kids to school. This is good work, and it has made a real difference to millions of people.
There were of course other candidates who were equally worthy. It's somewhat heartening that even in times as "interesting" as these, we can still find plenty of people whose work for peace and the betterment of humanity is more than worthy of international recognition - John Bolton obviously excluded.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/14/2006 12:44:00 AM
11
comments
Friday, October 13, 2006
Climate change: the cost of Marsden B
Today, we learned that the cost of our Kyoto obligation - in essence the cost of failing to act early to reduce emissions - has risen to $656 million. The primary reason for this rise is an increase in the expected price of carbon credits, from US$6 per tonne to US$9.65 per tonne.
Meanwhile, the Greens have pointed out that Mighty River's proposed coal-fired Marsden B power station is set to cost us $60 million a year to cover its emissions. That's $300 million over the first commitment period. It's unclear the extent to which this is included in the Projected Balance of Units (I think the answer is "yes, in the abstract"), but regardless of whether it is or isn't, it is clear that this thing is going to cost the public a large amount of money, which could be used for far better purposes. So why the hell are we letting the project go ahead?
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/13/2006 09:30:00 PM
0
comments
Labels:
Climate Change,
Coal,
Energy
Insulting the nationalists
Earlier in the year, Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk was charged with "insulting Turkishness" for saying in an interview with a Swiss magazine that
"Thirty thousand Kurds and a million Armenians were killed in these lands and nobody but me dares to talk about it."
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/13/2006 04:12:00 PM
8
comments
Law Commission opposes sedition
I mentioned last month that the Law Commission is reviewing New Zealand's sedition law. There's more news on this in a speech by Geoffrey Palmer to the Law Society - and its good:
A smaller project involving a review of seditious offences in the Crimes Act should be completed by March 2007. It is well advanced now, and a Consultation Paper will be placed on the Law Commission’s website on 17 October. Our task in carrying out this project has been much assisted by the fact that the Australian Law Reform Commission has had a similar project that is now completed. In essence, the consultation paper we are publishing will say that, in a free society, defaming the Government should not be an offence. We do not need the Crimes Act provisions against sedition. The elements of that offence that should remain criminal are covered by other existing provisions in the criminal law.
(Emphasis added)
I'll be looking forward to seeing that consultation document, and looking forward even more to seeing it finalised and its recommendations enacted. Sedition is an archaic law which must be repealed, and the sooner it is disposed of, the better.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/13/2006 03:23:00 PM
0
comments
Labels:
Sedition
A whip around
So, how are the parties hit with large bills by the Auditor-General's retrospective and arbitrary reinterpretation of the rules going to meet their obligations? Labour has announced a big whip around and is seeking donations from the public. You can either donate online here, call 0900-LABOUR, or send a cheque to
Labour Party
PO Box 784
Wellington
The Greens are also soliciting public donations. You can donate online here, by online banking to Kiwibank, Branch: Wellington, Account Number: 38 9005 0440479 00, or by cheque to
The Green Party
PO Box 11 652
Wellington
Repayment will be a massive task for both parties, similar in scale to pre-election fundraising. And as Peter Dunne pointed out last month, it is likely to have a serious effect on our democracy, hobbling their ability to contest the vote at the next election. Which seems to have been National's aim all along - being unable to win at the ballot box, they have sought to win at the bank instead. Which makes it all the more important that we institute public funding. Fortunately, the Auditor-General has just ensured that there will be a clear majority for it in Parliament.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/13/2006 02:09:00 PM
32
comments
Labels:
2005 Election,
Greens,
Labour
The problem of Privilege
A recent story about famous 70's drag-queen Carmen being honoured at Parliament contained an odd historical snippet which highlighted a serious problem with Parliamentary Privilege in this country:
Carmen's last visit to Parliament was when she was hauled before the Privileges Committee in 1975 for publicly naming a number of gay MPs.
This apparently "brought Parliament into disrepute", and so Carmen was forced to apologise. It was an outrageous abuse of power, akin to a prosecution for lese majeste - and the scary thing is that there is absolutely nothing stopping it from happening again. While calling the House into disrepute is no longer listed in the "Examples of Contempts" section of the Standing Orders (though "reflecting on the character or conduct of the House or of a member in the member's capacity as a member of the House" still is), there's nothing stopping them from putting it back in. And while such a provision would be contrary to the affirmation of freedom of expression in the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990, Parliamentary Privilege means Parliament is accountable only to itself, and so no court could enforce the BORA against it. The upshot is that Parliament could force people to apologise merely for insulting or laughing at them (or indeed, telling unwelcome truths about them) - which is surely exactly the sort of speech the BORA is supposed to protect.
Parliament needs certain privileges in order to operate effectively - for example, absolute protection for what is said in the House - but the "right" to police public opinion of politicians is neither necessary or desirable. While the era of such abuses seems to have passed (OTOH, they forced TV3 to apologise for showing footage of the Minister of Forty Winks), the power should be removed permanently, just to be on the safe side.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/13/2006 08:14:00 AM
4
comments
Labels:
Freedom of Speech,
Parliament
Thursday, October 12, 2006
Ten years of MMP
Ten years ago today, on October 12, 1996, New Zealand had its first MMP election. Since then Parliament has been more representative, both in terms of the parties represented in it and the faces of those representatives; more effective, particularly through the select committee process; and more trusted by the New Zealand public (the time series on "public perception of politicians and the political process" in Appendix D of the Justice and Electoral Committee's report on the Electoral (Reduction in Number of Members of Parliament) Amendment Bill [PDF] speaks for itself). We have also seen a significant decrease in the power of the executive compared to the legislature. As Helen Clark points out in her retrospective piece this morning,
Gone are the days when a small group within the Cabinet of a governing party could drive through radical change virtually unimpeded.
And of course there's the fact that now our governments actually have to win the support of a majority of the population, either directly at the ballot box or indirectly through coalition negotiations, rather than being able to rule with a bare plurality (and not even that, in 1978 and 1981). This counts for a lot, and has dramatically improved the legitimacy of our governing institutions.
Clark also notes that under MMP, "successful governing parties... are those which are able to work collaboratively with others". It is telling that opposition to MMP is centered on the National Party - a party which has demonstrated that it cannot play well with others, and which clearly sees MMP's weakening of the "executive dictatorship" as an impediment to its policy programme. Fortunately, the large number of new MPs entering Parliament at the last election may see them gradually adapting to the new political environment, rather than attempting to return to the unrepresentative government we had in the past.
MMP is still not perfect. As I've argued before, the 5% threshold is an arbitrary and undemocratic distortion which undermines proportionality, encourages large parties to try and eliminate smaller ones, and unfairly denies representation to smaller parties. It should be removed. A second problem is that unlike other parts of the Electoral Act, the MMP system itself is not entrenched, allowing politicians to meddle with it (possibly for their own electoral advantage). This needs to be corrected. But the general system itself is sound, and after ten years, I'm very happy with the way it has developed. MMP has been a positive influence on our politics; long may it continue!
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 05:43:00 PM
13
comments
Labels:
Democracy,
MMP
They're up
The Auditor-General's report on Parliamentary Services advertising expenditure and the Speaker's reply to it are now available from Parliament's website.
Update: Having read some of it: the Auditor-General concludes that almost half of all Parliamentary Services advertising expenditure in 2004 - 05, and over 60% of that in 05 - 06, was unlawful. Some parties - notably New Zealand First in 05-04, and the Greens and Labour in 05-06, had almost their entire spending considered unlawful, while many had over 50%. National seems to have been very well-behaved, though that's probably due to being wealthy enough to wage a permanant campaign with laundered funds, rather than relying on Parliamentary communications to advise the public of their policies. As a general comment, Parliamentary Services disagreed violently with the A-G's interpretation of the rules, arguing that they only outlawed explicit solicitation rather than anything which might persuade anyone to vote for a party. This difference of opinion is the key reason why so many parties have been caught out.
Update 2: having got to the end: the A-G has recommended a review of the Parliamentary Service's financial procedures to ensure they spend money properly, and restated his prior recommendation that the system of funding political parties be reviewed. The Speaker agrees with these recommendations (while disagreeing quite strongly with his interpretation of the rules, which she clearly regards as both retrospective and outlawing a great deal of Parliamentary activity - e.g. holding public meetings), and furthermore proposes retrospective validating legislation on the basis that this is standard practice and mere repayment is not sufficient to erase the unlawfulness of the spending. She will also be asking the parties to respond to the report and consider repaying the money, if only in the interests of restoring public confidence in Parliament.
I suspect we will see validating legislation - which National will oppose - and a lot of parties are suddenly going to become very keen on public funding or changing the rules so they can continue to actually talk with their constituents without having someone leaning over their shoulder to ensure that they don't persuade them of anything.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 02:31:00 PM
25
comments
Labels:
2005 Election
Drawn
The usual ballot for Member's Bills was held today, and the following bills were drawn:
- Local Electoral (Repeal of Race-Based Representation) Amendment Bill (Tony Ryall)
- Treaty of Waitangi (Removal of Conflict of Interest) Amendment Bill (Pita Paraone)
- Foreshore and Seabed Act (Repeal) Bill (Tariana Turia)
So, we're voting on the Treaty then. I can't really see either of the first two passing - the Labour/Green/Maori Party bloc has the numbers, so can vote them down unless they think the ideas are worthy of select committee examination. The last will be interesting, and will open the festering wound of Labour's betrayal of Maori over the foreshore, but I think it will ultimately be voted down (neither New Zealand First or United Future will really want to revisit the topic). But there'll likely be plenty of fireworks all round, and more sickening banging of the race drum by National (which, on the positive side, ought to bury any hope of a Maori Party support for a future National government).
There was a host of new bills in the ballot today. In addition to Turia's bill, there was also:
- Marine Animals Protection Law Reform Bill (Jeanette Fitzsimons)
- Resource Management (Aquaculture) Amendment Bill (Phil Heatley)
- New Zealand Taxpayer Bill of Rights Bill (Rodney Hide)
- Fireworks Safety Bill (Marian Hobbs)
- Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment Bill (Heather Roy)
I'm trying to get hold of these, and will do another "In The Ballot" post as soon as I have enough.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 12:40:00 PM
4
comments
Labels:
Members Bills,
Parliament
Carnival of the liberals
The twenty-third Carnival of the Liberals is now up at World Wide Webers.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 10:01:00 AM
0
comments
Labels:
Liberalism,
Links
How high?
While writing last night's post, a sick question occured to me: how high is Bush's pyramid of skulls? So, I tried to work it out: (Warning: sick maths follows):
- Assume a cubical skull (I just love the way physicists say things like this; its so they stack nicely);
- Assume the volume of a single skull is about 2 litres, or 0.002 cubic meters (not unreasonable, looking at the cast on my mantlepiece, and if its too large, call it packing fraction);
- So the volume of 655,000 cubical skulls is 13,100 cubic meters - enough to fill five standard Olympic swimming pools or bury a rugby field to a depth of 1.3 meters;
- If we use a 45 degree cone, with height equal to radius (to make the maths simple), we have v = 1/3 pi r3. Solving for r gives a final height of 23.2 meters, or 76 feet for those still stuck in the dark ages. So if stacked on the White House lawn, they would be taller than the White House.
Interestingly, the above website also gives the floor area of the White House: 55,000 square feet, or 5100 square meters. So Bush's pyramid of skulls would fill every floor to a depth of 2.5 meters - burying the President and his staff in the death they have caused.
Correction: As pointed out in the comments, I'm out by a factor of ten in the total volume, which means the pile is somewhat smaller (only half the height of the White House). Teach me to use a calculator in the morning...
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 09:44:00 AM
5
comments
Labels:
Geekery,
Iraq
Faith-based Presidency
George Bush responds to the news that the death-toll of his little adventure in Iraq has hit 655,000:
"I stand by the figure that a lot of innocent people have lost their life. Six-hundred thousand or whatever they guess at is just not credible"
Because clearly, some number the President pulled out of his arse is far more "credible" than one calculated by people who actually went there and looked.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 09:06:00 AM
4
comments
Labels:
Iraq
Pyramid of skulls
Two years ago, a team of epidemiologists at the John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Heath in Baltimore published a study in the Lancet estimating that the US invasion and occupation of Iraq had led to approximately one hundred thousand excess deaths. While the study caused a storm of outrage among supporters of the war, its methodology and conclusions were generally regarded as robust and repeatable. The authors of the study have now done exactly that, repeating their sampling with a greater number of clusters. Their midpoint estimate for the number of excess deaths is now 655,000.
Six hundred and fifty-five thousand - that's 2.5% of the Iraqi population, dead due to America's war. Even the bottom of the confidence interval - 392,979 - is thirteen times higher than Bush's estimate of 30,000 dead, and more than twice as high as the estimated 182,000 killed in Saddam's Al-Anfal campaign of genocide against the Kurds, for which he is currently on trial. What does that suggest about the eventual fate of the architects of this obscene occupation?
(I am steadfastly Not Thinking about the top of the confidence interval. It doesn't top a million, but its certainly within reach).
Thanks to George Bush, 500 more Iraqis are dying a day than died under Saddam. 92% of them are dying due to violence, and 31% of those deaths are directly attributable to US forces. The rest is mostly gunshot wounds, car bombs, and other explosions (the researchers don't seem to have included a category for death squads). 500 a day. Maybe someone should start piling the skulls on the White House lawn?
For a war that was supposedly waged to help the Iraqi people, this has done precisely the opposite. "First, do no harm" is a basic principle of medicine. Maybe we should think about making it a principle of foreign policy too.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 02:00:00 AM
38
comments
Labels:
Iraq
Manukau prostitution: the vote
Tim Barnett's office was kind enough to email me scans of the tally sheets for the vote on the Manukau City Council (Control of Street Prostitution) Bill, so here are the details:
Ayes
- Jim Anderton (Progressive Coalition, Wigram)
- Chris Auchinvole (National, List)
- David Bennett (National, Hamilton East)
- Jackie Blue (National, List)
- Chester Borrows (National, Whanganui)
- Peter Brown (New Zealand First, List)
- Gerry Brownlee (National, Ilam)
- David Carter (National, List)
- John Carter (National, Northland)
- Bob Clarkson (National, Tauranga)
- Johnathan Coleman (National, Northcote)
- Judith Collins (National, Clevedon)
- Gordon Copeland (United Future, List)
- Jacqui Dean (National, Otago)
- Brian Donnelly (New Zealand First, List)
- Peter Dunne (United Future, Ohariu-Belmont)
- Bill English (National, Clutha-Southland)
- Taito Phillip Field (Labour, Mangere)
- Craig Foss (National, Tukituki)
- Sandra Goudie (National, Coromandel)
- Tim Groser (National, List)
- Nathan Guy (National, List)
- George Hawkins (Labour, Manurewa)
- Phillip Heatley (National, Whangarei)
- Paul Hutchison (National, Port Waikato)
- John Key (National, Helensville)
- Colin King (National, kaikoura)
- Wayne Mapp (National, North Shore)
- Ron Mark (New Zealand First, List)
- Pita Paraone (New Zealand First, List)
- Allan Peachey (National, Tamaki)
- Winston Peters (New Zealand First, List)
- Ross Robertson (Labour, Manukau East)
- Eric Roy (National, Invercargill)
- Tony Ryall (National, Bay of Plenty)
- Nick Smith (National, Nelson)
- Barbara Stewart (New Zealand First, List)
- Paul Swain (Labour, Rimutaka)
- Lindsay Tisch (National, Piako)
- Anne Tolley (National, East Coast)
- Chris Tremain (National, Napier)
- Judy Turner (United Future, List)
- Nicky Wagner (National, List)
- Kate Wilkinson (National, List)
- Maurice Williamson (National, Pakuranga)
- Doug Woolerton (New Zealand First, List)
Noes
- Rick Barker (Labour, List)
- Tim Barnett (Labour, Christchurch Central)
- Paula Bennett (National, List)
- David Benson-Pope (Labour, Dunedin South)
- Georgina Beyer (Labour, List)
- Mark Blumsky (National, List)
- Sue Bradford (Green, List)
- Don Brash (National, List)
- Mark Burton (Labour, Taupo)
- Chris Carter (Labour, Te Atatu)
- Steve Chadwick (Labour, Rotorua)
- Charles Chauvel (Labour, List)
- Ashraf Choudhary (Labour, List)
- Helen Clark (Labour, Mt Albert)
- Brian Connell (National, Rakaia)
- Clayton Cosgrove (Labour, Waimakariri)
- Michael Cullen (Labour, List)
- David Cunliffe (Labour, New Lynn)
- Lianne Dalziel (Labour, Christchurch East)
- Harry Duynhoven (Labour, New Plymouth)
- Ruth Dyson (Labour, Banks Peninsula)
- Russell Fairbrother (Labour, List)
- Darien Fenton (Labour, List)
- Christopher Finlayson (National, List)
- Jeanette Fitzsimons (Green, List)
- Te Ururoa Flavell (Maori Party, Waiariki)
- Martin Gallagher (Labour, Hamilton West)
- Phil Goff (Labour, Mt Roskill)
- Jo Goodhew (National, Aoraki)
- Mark Gosche (Labour, Maungakiekie)
- Hone Harawira (Maori Party, Te Tai Tokerau)
- Ann Hartley (Labour, List)
- John Hayes (National, Wairarapa)
- Tau Henare (National, List)
- Dave Hereora (Labour, List)
- Rodney Hide (ACT, Epsom)
- Marian Hobbs (Labour, Wellington Central)
- Pete Hodgson (Labour, Dunedein North)
- Parekura Horomia (Labour, Ikaroa-Rawhiti)
- Darren Hughes (Labour, Otaki)
- Shane Jones (Labour, List)
- Sue Kedgley (Green, List)
- Annette King (Labour, Rongotai)
- Winnie Laban (Labour, Mana)
- Keith Locke (Green, List)
- Moana Mackey (Labour, List)
- Steve Maharey (Labour, Palmerston North)
- Nanaia Mahuta (Labour, Tainui)
- Trevor Mallard (Labour, Hutt South)
- Murray McCully (National, East Coast Bays)
- Sue Moroney (Labour, List)
- Damien O'Connor (Labour, West Coast-Tasman)
- Mahara Okeroa (Labour, Te Tai Tonga)
- David Parker (Labour, List)
- Jill Pettis (Labour, List)
- Lynne Pillay (Labour, Waitakere)
- Simon Power (National, Rangitikei)
- Katherine Rich (National, List)
- Mita Ririnui (Labour, List)
- Heather Roy (ACT, List)
- Dover Samuels (Labour, List)
- Pita Sharples (Maori Party, Tamaki-Makaurau)
- Clem Simich (National, List)
- Lockwood Smith (National, Rodney)
- Nandor Tanczos (Green, List)
- Georgina te Heuheu (National, List)
- Judith Tizard (Labour, Auckland Central)
- Metiria Turei (Green, List)
- Tariana Turia (Maori Party, Te Tai Hauauru)
- Margaret Wilson (Labour, List)
- Pansy Wong (National, List)
- Richard Worth (National, List)
- Dianne Yates (Labour, List)
No vote is recorded for Shane Ardern or Maryan Street.
The results can also be viewed at the CommoNZ archive of conscience votes here (which allows them to be searched and compared with votes on previous bills).
So, Labour's usual suspects (Hawkins, Field, Swain and Robertson) supported it, while the rest opposed. Meanwhile, National turned out to have rather more liberals than expected (and strangely, Don Brash seems to have recovered his conscience, while John Key is now voting with the Brethren). The big surprises are that Jim Anderton supported it (showing that on social issues, the "progressives" aren't), while ACT acted like an actual liberal party for once.
And as a final note, I am constantly surprised at how helpful our MPs and Parliamentary staff are if you ask them nicely, and I wouldn't be able to do this sort of work without them.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/12/2006 12:17:00 AM
7
comments
Labels:
Liberalism,
Manukau Prostitution Bill,
Parliament,
Prostitution
Wednesday, October 11, 2006
New Zealand First and Climate Change
United Future has now put out a press release applauding the government's climate change initiatives - while carefully sidestepping the question of emissions trading. I'm still trying to get hold of Gordon Copeland to ask him about that, but in the meantime, following his gloat in the House yesterday about the demise of the carbon tax, I thought I should also ask New Zealand First's Peter Brown about the issue.
New Zealand First's position on climate change was spelled out in their newsletter last month. They accept that climate change is a problem, but are a little confused on the precise details. What they don't accept, according to the discussion I had with Mr Brown today, is that the solution has to revolve around taxes. Instead, they think it is all about technology and trees - though why that technology would be adopted or those trees planted in the absence of an economic signal seems to be an unasked question. One of their chief concerns is that they don't want to see the "average punter" paying higher prices for electricity or petrol (they are especially concerned about the impact of high electricity prices on the elderly, who are already "freezing to death" in winter in some parts of the country). If there is to be a tax (or presumably any other form of economic instrument), they would prefer to see the revenue recycled into research (the thought of other forms of recycling e.g. into afforestation schemes or insulation refits so that the elderly don't freeze to death in winter doesn't seem to have occurred to them).
Strangely, they have "no view" on emissions trading, according to Brown - though this is probably because they don't really know what it involves. Apparently, no-one has even raised the issue with them (and they clearly don't see it as a key area they should focus their policy resources on).
When asked whether they would regard a pilot emissions trading regime as a breach of their confidence and supply agreement, Brown pointed out that the carbon tax got one line in the agreement, which promised a review. So its up in the air whether they would regard it as going back on their deal or not.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/11/2006 05:53:00 PM
3
comments
Labels:
Climate Change,
NZ First
Crunch day for Manukau prostitution
The Manukau City Council (Control of Street Prostitution) Bill is due for its second reading today. There's been little news about it since the Local Government and Environment Committee recommended that it not proceed, and I'm not even sure at this stage whether it will face a party vote or conscience vote. I suspect the latter, in which case I expect the bill to fail by a significant margin as National's liberals join with Labour (sans George Hawkins), the Greens, Maori Party and ACT in voting it down. I'll post news as soon as I hear it, and details of the vote when I can obtain them.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/11/2006 01:34:00 PM
1 comments
Labels:
Manukau Prostitution Bill,
Parliament
Free Thomas Yadegary
For the past twenty three months, Thomas Yadegary has been imprisoned without charge or trial in Mount Eden prison. Like Ahmed Zaoui before him, he is being held under a Warrant of Commitment under the Immigration Act, which effectively allows indefinite detention without trial for those awaiting deportation. Unlike Ahmed Zaoui, he is not being held for security reasons - Yadegary lived freely in New Zealand for twelve years prior to his imprisonment - but rather because he has refused to sign the Iranian passport application required for him in order to be deported to his home country. He has refused to do this because as a convert to Christianity, he fears persecution if returned to Iran.
Yadegary's fears are well-founded. Iran is an Islamic Republic, and engages in the institutional discrimination and repression of other religious (including "heretical" branches of Islam, such as Sunnis and Sufis). Here are a few snippets from the US State Department's 2006 International Religious Freedom Country Report for Iran:
Conversion of a Muslim to a non-Muslim religion is considered apostasy under the law and is punishable by the death penalty, although it was unclear whether this punishment had been enforced in recent years. Similarly, non-Muslims could not proselytize Muslims without putting their own lives at risk. Evangelical church leaders were subject to pressure from authorities to sign pledges that they would not evangelize Muslims or allow Muslims to attend church services.[...]
On November 22, 2005, a Muslim convert to Christianity, Ghorban Tori, was kidnapped from his house in the northeast and killed. His body was later returned to his house. Tori was a pastor at an independent house church of converted Christians. After the killing, security officials searched his house for Bibles and banned Christian books in Persian. In the previous week, according to some sources, the Ministry of Intelligence and Security arrested and tortured ten Christians in several cities.
On May 2, 2006, a Muslim convert to Christianity, Ali Kaboli, was taken into custody in Gorgan, after several years of police surveillance and threatened prosecution if he did not leave the country. He was interrogated and was held incommunicado. So far no charges have been filed against him.
The government and RSAA's response to this atmosphere of persecution is to deny that it is a problem because Yadegary can "practice his faith in secret". This is simply wiping our hands of the problem. To point out the obvious analogy, this is like telling a Jew fleeing pre-war Nazi Germany that they could simply hide. Yadegary is exactly the sort of person the Refugee Convention is supposed to protect, and our attempts to deport him show that our government is not living up to its legal or its moral obligations in this case.
Posted by
Idiot/Savant
at
10/11/2006 12:06:00 PM
4
comments
Labels:
Detention Without Trial,
Human Rights,
Immigration,
Thomas Yadegary





